Thursday, 22 April 2010

(-) Ossi

STUTTGART


On 15th April, a labour court in Stuttgart ruled that former East Germans are not an ethnic group. German  newspapers talk about "the prevalence of negative stereotypes" (Smee, 2010) about people from the former GDR and cultural tentions. The case where a woman born in the former East Berlin sued a window manufacturer she applied for work in the southwestern city, for ethnic discrimination. Her CV was returned with "(-) Ossi"*, but the company claimed the minus sign meant lack of qualification. 

* "Ossi," based on the German word Ost, or East, often used negatively

The Stuttgart labor court rejected her claim and noted that East Germans were not an ethnic group, with the judge saying "more must be considered than just a person's regional origin... while at the same time conceding that the term "Ossi" could be taken as a negative label." (Smee, 2010)


The following editorials are from Smee's article.

Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung
"Only ignorant 'Wessis' (the nickname for those from western Germany) could label people from Mecklenburg, Thuringia and Saxony as belonging to the same ethnic group. Their only similarity is that they were all, to some extent, shaped by the socialist state during 40 years of the German Democratic Republic -- regardless if they personally supported the system or not. These shared experiences continue to affect those people today. It remains one of the biggest political mistakes that no one has tried to imagine the situation from the perspective of those in the former East Germany."  "We have as little influence over our origins as over our gender. For that reason it doesn't appear far-fetched to use anti-discriminatory legislation in such cases. Whatever one thinks of the General Equal Treatment Act, any employer who is stupid enough to reject an applicant on grounds other than their qualifications should not be surprised by a barrage of negative criticism."  "Meanwhile, there is something positive to be drawn from all this: Such cases serve to reinforce the inner unity of this country."

Süddeutsche Zeitung
"The Stuttgart labor court's decision firstly serves as good sideshow -- but it also focuses attention on legal issues. The detailed legal analysis is not quite as funny as a sideshow, but it is rewarding: It leads to the conclusion that the verdict is wrong."  "The Labor Court dismissed the case of the East Berlin-born job applicant who had been rejected by her employer on the grounds that she was an 'Ossi'. The court ruled that Ossis were not an ethnic group, based on the General Equal Treatment Act."  "That may well be true, but we also have the German constitution. Article 3, paragraph 3 of the constitution clearly states that no one should be discriminated against 'because of sex, race or language and' -- wait for it -- 'due to his homeland and origin'. Without a doubt, the label 'Ossi' refers to origin and homeland." 

Frankfurter Rundschau
"The term 'Ossi' may be offensive, but it is not covered by the General Equal Treatment Act. Of course it matters whether someone went to the Free German Youth (East Germany's official socialist youth movement) or was forbidden from their chosen professional path due to their allegedly mistaken political beliefs."  "For this generation at least, the term 'Ossi' remains crucial to many people's identity. In this particular case, the label 'Ossi' was not used neutrally, but negatively and thoughtlessly. Maybe the judge wanted to use this case to provoke awareness of a legally gray area. Hopefully the applicant will continue her fight." 

The Nordkurier, a regional paper from northeastern Germany
"The white, er, wise man, has rule: 'Ossis' aren't Indians. ... But plaintiff Gaberiele S. and her attorney have already done a lot by drawing considerable public attention to this issue. She should be praised for taking this to court rather than just accepting it."  "Too old, too fat, too costly, too sick, too female, too 'Ossi' -- in the daily fight for jobs many candidates face discriminatory judgments, either directly, or implied. Sometimes these are careless -- but rarely are they justifiable. It is fair enough, and even important, when the victims of such hurtful comments try to defend themselves and recover their self-esteem."

Ostthüringer Zeitung, a regional paper based in Gera, eastern Germany
"Thanks go to the judge who upheld that East Germans are not an ethinic group -- a fact that no one doubted in the first place. Anyone who grew up in East Germany, knows that people differed greatly across the former country, from Thuringia to Saxony to those dwelling in the major cities. It was German reunification that first embedded the clear categories of Easterners and Westerners. Those German generalizations always leave one group feeling discriminated against, rather than giving them a sense of 'Ossi' pride." 

Smee, J. (2919) 'Ossis Aren't Indians' [Online] http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/0,1518,689403,00.html [22/04/2010]

DDP/The Local (2010) Court Rules Against 'Ossi' Discrimination Case. [Online] http://www.thelocal.de/society/20100415-26575.html?utm_source=email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=124 [22/04/2010]
Goebel, N. & Penfold, C. (ed.) (2010) Former East Germans are Not an Ethnic Group, Court Rules. [Online] http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,5471294,00.html [22/04/2010]

SMD/Spiegel (2010) Landmark 'Ossi' Discrimination Case Court to Decide if East Germans are Ethnic Group. [Online]

Designing Empty Cities

Where demolition is unavoidable in Aschersleben, there
are huge pieces of contemporary art, as big as houses


Müller, R. (2010) When Less Is More: Eastern German Project Provides Hope for Shrinking Cities. [Online]
http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/0,1518,688152,00.html#ref=nlint [22/04/2010]

Sunday, 18 April 2010

The Invisible Wall by Stephan Kaluza



Although I didn't have €50 to spend on the book I found, The Invisible Wall by Stephan Kaluza, his website provides images as well as essays by Heinz-Norbert Jocks and David Galloway from the book.

Wilhelmstraße

There is also an interview online, with scenes of the photographer on location  (in German) by Institut für Kunstdokumentation.


Galloway, D. (2009) Walking the Line. [Online]
Institut für Kunstdokumentation  [2010] Stephan Kaluza - project Berlin Wall.  [Online] http://vimeo.com/6414799  [18/04/2010]
Jocks, H.-N. (2009) The Spirit of the Absent. [Online]

Wednesday, 7 April 2010

Berlin Stories


Berlin Stories is a series radio broadcast on NPR Worldwide, produced and directed by writers. The logo is designed by Christoph Niemann.

Berlin Stories [2010] http://berlinstories.org/ [07/04/2010] 
Niemann, C. (2008) http://christophniemann.com/ [07/04/2010] 

Metrofarm: The Wall


"It is delivered in a custom-made cardboard box and can be ordered directly from Metrofarm.
It's dimensions are:
Height 16cm, depth 11cm, width 10cm,
weight 550g" (Metrofarm, 2006)

Metrofarm (2006) The Wall. [Online] http://www.metrofarm.net/thewall/?image=3 [07/04/2010]

Megan O’Grady on 1989


O’Grady, M. (2009) Letter From Berlin: After The Wall. [Online] http://www.vogue.com/voguedaily/2009/11/letter-from-berlin/ [06/04/2010]

Tuesday, 6 April 2010

Washington Post Gallery

Photograph by Richard A. Lipski

A slideshow with narration by the Washington Post editor Marc Fisher, who in 1989 was the Post's Berlin correspondent. 

Washington Post (2009) Tearing Down the Wall in 1989. [online] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/gallery/2009/11/04/GA2009110403729.html [06/04/2010]

Wall and Fashion



Art is Everywhere (2009) Another Form of Canvas. [online] http://www.ashley-spencer.com/ArtIsEverywhere/?tag=berlin-wall-art [06/04/2010]
Comenetz, J. (2009) in Casciato, P. (ed.) "Berlin Wall Graffiti Returns as Leather Fashion" [online] http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE5583YC20090609 [06/04/2010]
Mauerkleider [2010] East Side Gallery Goes Fashion - by Rodan. [online] http://www.mauerkleider.de/index.html [06/04/2010]
The Fashionables (2009) German Designer Commemorates The Fall Of The Berlin Wall. [online] http://www.thefashionables.com/2009/07/german-designer-commemorates-the-fall-of-the-berlin-wall/ [06/04/2010]

Heil Democracy!

Heil Democracy!

Grugel, M. L. (2009) Heil Democracy! [online] http://www.nosugar-studio.co.uk/ [06/04/2010]

Sunday, 4 April 2010

Absolut Wall


1. Purpose - selling swedish merchandise to a Berlin audience by familiarizing it to it's audience.

2. Serious audience- Definitely targets German and in particular a Berlin audience. cultural/educated/
metropolitan/mature. The age targeted could be a more young/middle-age crowd. The fact that it is
displayed in a museum allows the ad to reach more of the intellectual and historically-aware

3. Argument: connection to symbols Germans can relate to on a historical, informational, and emotional level. Relate the product, vodka, which is emotionless, with the emotions that were felt when the wall came down. Celebration and feelings of freedom were felt when the wall came down, and the ad attempts to recreate these feelings through the vodka. Jubilation. Also attempts to remove the negative stigma
typically associated with alcohol. Instead of depicting a rowdy, vulgar crowd it portrays the vodka more for socializing purposes than for the typical idea of "getting wasted."

3b. Pathos- drawing an emotional response through the portrayal of the Berlin Wall as well as a patriotic one through the German flag. (unification under one flag)
Ethos- placing the ad in a museum an attempt to relate the Swedish drink to the German audience through knowledge of German culture (flag, wall, language).

3c. triangular division of the ad with bipolar parts: first, the form of product and the wall
second, the name of product and synoymous meaning of absolut
third, the place Berlin

4. Bending and connecting two things that were not initially connected- Swedish vodka and German audience, oppression of the wall and freedom of choice. The wall no longer keeps things out.

5. Kairos- placing events in context, the knocking down of the Berlin Wall is recent, it's a current event, so it makes since to address it. Challenges cultural norms- puts alcohol into a cultivated place
like a museum, and gives it emotional and historical connection. A move towards unification, not only between East and West, but on a larger global context.

Cross-Cultural Blog (2007) The Rhetoric of Visual Ads: Absolut Berlin. [online]http://www.stanford.edu/group/ccr/blog/2007/12/the_rhetoric_of_visual_ads_abs.html [04/04/2010]

Mikhail Gorbachev with a Louis Vuitton


Mikhail Gorbachev drives pass the Berlin Wall, in a Louis Vuitton campaign. This photograph by Annie Leibovitz caused speculations, as the magazine headline reads "The Murder of Litvinenko: They Wanted to Give Up the Suspect for $7,000". Both Louis Vuitton and its agency Ogilvy & Mather denied the link to the case of Alexander V. Litvinenko, the former KGB spy who died after being poisoned with polonium 210 (Levin, 2007).

"Our company has absolutely no intention to pass any other messages than the one on ‘personal journeys", claimed Pietro Beccari, director of marketing at Louis Vuitton. Robert Passikoff noted "once you declare it was an overt and planned act, it has no meaning" (Levin, 2007).

Levin, D. (2007) Louis Vuitton Ad Shows Gorbachev Accompanied by Subversive Text. [online]
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/05/business/media/05vuitton.html [04/04/2010]

Aung San Suu Kyi, Lancia and Chrysler


This is a 30 second clip from a Fiat group online and TV campaign, associating Lancia Delta with World Summit of Nobel Peace Laureates, and calling for unconditional release for Burmese leader Aung San Suu Kyi [The Inspiration Room, 2010]. It was later adopted by Chrysler with similarly husky voice but less words, and a Chrysler.


The Lancia ad is also available in German, French and Italian. 

The Inspiration Room [2010] Fiat and Chrysler Back Aung San Suu Kyi. [online]  http://theinspirationroom.com/daily/2009/fiat-and-chrysler-back-aung-san-suu-kyi/ [04/04/2010]


Your Face for Freedom [2010] Freedom oOnly has One Face. [online] http://www.yourfaceforfreedom.org/ [04/04/2010]

Saturday, 3 April 2010

Berlin Wall in a Toilet

The Berlin Wall in a Las Vegas casino toilet

Greer, G. (2010) It was a Stunning Work of Art – So why is the Wall Hanging in a Las Vegas Loo? [online] 
http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/2010/feb/14/germaine-greer-berlin-wall-thierry-noir [03/04/2010]
Stein, J.D. (2007)Urinate on History in Vegas. [online] http://gridskipper.com/archives/entries/059/59384.php [03/04/2010]


Wikipedia [2010] List of Berlin Wall Segments. [online] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Berlin_Wall_segments [03/04/2010]

“Before you even think you need it”


"Before you even think you need it" boasts a DHL advert with a man who has just unpacked a hammer. The Berlin Wall and the Brandenburg gate can be can be seen through his window. The ad was created by Gabor Spielmann and Bruno Almeidaat at Ogilvy Budapest, Hungary, and photographer Pal Nánási [The Inspiration Room, 2010].

The Inspiration Room [2010] DHL Hammer for Berlin Wall. [online] http://theinspirationroom.com/daily/2009/dhl-hammer-for-berlin-wall/ [03/04/2010]

Windows and Walls



This is a Microsoft advert for Windows, "designed to highlight that technology is supposed to help people break through barriers and overcome obstacles" (Flores, 2008). 


"The 20th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall has inspired many advertising campaigns. Microsoft Windows has hit the nail with its “Break Down the Walls” campaign targeted at its own software sales staff. It concealed a letter of invitation to sales promotion inside concrete which had to be broken with hammer. Sales employees could also win a trip to Berlin by joining sales promotion. The idea was to inspire them to break down walls and build up sales." (Katti, 2009)

Flores, C. (2008) Windows: Life without Walls. [online]  http://windowsteamblog.com/blogs/windowsvista/archive/2008/09/18/windows-life-without-walls.aspx [03/04/2010]
Katti, M. (2009)Berlin Wall Fall Inspired Advertising Campaigns. [online] http://trendsupdates.com/berlin-wall-fall-inspired-advertising-campaigns/ [03/04/2010]

Beck's and the Berlin Wall


I'd previously found a short clip from "an integrated marketing and public relations campaign" (The Inspiration Room, 2009) by Beck's, for the anniversary of the opening of the Berlin Wall. Here are some posters and another by Tim Buesing (2009).

Dominated to Liberated

Oppression to Expression

Grief to Relief


Buesing studied in Berlin and the photographs in the clip below, 20 Years 20 Hours in Berlin, are from an exhibition commissioned by Beck's (Buesing, 2009).


Buesing, T. (2009) 20 Years – 20 Hours: Commemorating the Fall of the Berlin Wall. [online] http://between0and1.org/2009/10/26/20-years-20-hours/ [03/04/2010]
Buesing, T. (2009) Commemorating the Fall of the Berlin Wall Part 2. [online] http://between0and1.org/2009/10/29/fall-of-berlin-wall/ [03/04/2010]
The Inspiration Room (2009) Becks Berlin Wall in Australia. [online] http://theinspirationroom.com/daily/2009/becks-berlin-wall-in-australia/ [03/04/2010]

Thursday, 1 April 2010

Image Fulgurator by Julius von Bismarck



"People’s great trust in their photographic reproductions of reality was what motivated me to develop the *Image Fulgurator*. A camera can be used as a personal memory tool, since people do not doubt the veracity of their own photographs. Hence, photos can reproduce the reality of an individual environment or public space. At sacred or popular locations, or those having a political connotation, an intervention with the Fulgurator can be particularly effective. Especially objects with a special aura or great symbolic power are good targets for this kind of manipulation. In other words, with the Fulgurator it is possible to have a lasting effect on those kinds of individual moments and events that become accessible to the masses only because they are preserved photographically." (Von Bismarck, 2007/8)

Wowereit powered by "O2" Klaus Wowereit (mayor of Berlin)
 at the opening of the art fair "ART FORUM 2008"

Von Bismarck, J. (2007/8) Image Fulgurator. [online] http://www.juliusvonbismarck.com/ulgurator/fertig.html [01/04/2010]

Wednesday, 31 March 2010

Christoph Niemann and his Audience



"I fear that my most basic inspiration to draw and design is a genuine insecurity. Hence, there always has been a (more or less) defined character sitting in the back of my head giving me imaginary thumbs ups&downs. That character changes depending on the assignment: when I was sixteen I would usually think of one of the girls that I tried to impress with my drawings (I was usually spot on with guessing what they liked — except that they just liked the drawings but wouldn't make the leap to fall in love with me). By now I have fairly established set of avatars that are based on real people, that I run things by in my head. When I give a talk, I usually try to find out if there is someone in the audience that I know, and then turn that person into my mental target audience." [Niemann, in Frank, 2010]

Frank, Z. [2010] Christoph Niemann. [online] http://www.zefrank.com/audience/#christoph [31/03/2010]
Niemann, C. (2009) Over the Wall. [online] http://niemann.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/18/over-the-wall/ [31/03/2010]

Tuesday, 23 March 2010

Thatcher's View on Unification

Binyon, M. (2009) Thatcher Told Gorbachev Britain Did Not Want German Reunification. [online] http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article6829735.ece [23/03/2010]
Volkery, C. (2009) The Iron Lady's Views on German Reunification: 'The Germans Are Back!' [online] http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/0,1518,648364,00.html [23/03/2010]

Wallstalgia

16 % of Germans polled by Emnid for Bild said rebuilding the Wall "would be the best thing that could happen" (AFP, 2010). Nearly one in four "sometimes think it would be better if the Berlin Wall were still there" claimed the AFP report, adding that there was very little difference between the former East (23%) and West (24%) Germans for the division to be recreated.


In 2009, Pew Research Center conducted a on the level of satisfaction survey across the former Eastern countries (Pew Research Center, 2009). Their research shows that in both former-East and -West Germany, people are less positive about the unification than they were 20 years ago. Overall, there is more positive opinion in the former East [fig.1].

[fig.1]Opinions of German Reunification
*The question wording was slightly different

There is a stark gap in how the unification has affected their life, where majority in East say their life is better off, majority of the people polled in the West feel that they were not affected [fig.2].

[fig.2] How Life has Changed as a Result of Unification

[fig.3] Satisfaction with Life

There is another gap in East-West perception over satisfaction with life [fig.3]. Between 1991 and 2009, there is 28% rise in satisfaction in East, a slight decrease in West. In comparison to other East European nations, the Germans favour democratic government over strong leader [fig.4].

[fig.4] Democratic Government vs. Strong Leader

How the German people perceive the issue of unification varies, traits being evident between the East-West groups.

AFP (2010) Survey Finds Support for Return of Berlin Wall. [online] http://www.france24.com/en/20100315-survey-finds-support-return-berlin-wall [23/03/2010]
Pew Research Center (2009) Highlights from 2009 Pulse of Europe Survey. [online] http://pewglobal.org/docs/?DocID=26 [23/03/2010]

Monday, 22 March 2010

Werner's Wall and His Audience

Werner Schloemerkemper, 75, starts to build a wall in Paul Cotter's short film The Berlin Wall, which also reflects Berliners' divided opinions of history. Berliners, including his neighbours who are unaware of his motivations, speculate and respond in various ways - some react positively and offer to help build the wall higher, whereas some of his neighbours in oppose the idea of a new wall which divides the community, projecting "their own biases and feelings onto his act" [Cotter, 2010]. "To Werner, the wall was a symbol of love, but to most people the wall was a symbol of hatred, of division, of separation, of dislike", but he never explains why.


"This opened up questions about the nature of public opinion. What it means, how groups of people so often develop opinions... people often project their own, already-formed opinions onto whatever they see in front of them" [Cotter, 2010]. Werner is uninterested in his neighbours opinions and remains an isolated architect, only true to his intentions. 

Cotter, P. [2010] The Berlin Wall Press Kit. [online] http://www.paulcotter.net/presskits/PressemappeENG.pdf [22/03/2010]
Cotter, P. (2010) The Berlin Wall. [online] http://www.paulcotter.net/theberlinwall/ [10/03/2010] 

Wednesday, 17 March 2010

Berlin/Wall by David Hare

Belvoir St Theatre [2010] David Hare's Berlin/Wall. [online] http://www.belvoir.com.au/340_whatson_archive.php?production_id=272 [17/03/2010]
WNYC (2009) "Berlin/Wall". [online] http://www.wnyc.org/shows/lopate/episodes/2009/05/12/segments/131671 [17/03/2010]

Tuesday, 16 March 2010

Germany through Express

Michael Cummings
15 Nov 1989

Express editorial cartoons, published days within the opening of the Berlin Wall and the German unification, relate Germany to its Nazi past - a view similarly shared by Margaret Thatcher. 

Ronald Carl Giles
7 Oct 1990
Cummings, M. (1989) Artist:Michael Cummings. [online] http://www.cartoons.ac.uk/browse/cartoon_item/anytext=german%20unification?page=6 [16/03/2010]
Giles, R.C. (1990) Artist:Giles; Ronald Carl (1916-1995). [online] http://www.cartoons.ac.uk/browse/cartoon_item/anytext=german%20unification?page=8 [16/03/2010]

Sunday, 14 March 2010

Wall on the Head

"Hair sculpture is an artistic journey into ancient memory" and "transcends boundaries of culture, the plastic arts, performance and fashion" (Niedzialek, 2007).

Berlin Wall

Glasnot [sic] and America the Beautiful

Niedzialek, T. (2007) Earth Hair. [online] http://www.earthhairsculpture.com/sculpt.html [14/03/2010]

A Hotel on the Border Strip


Etienne Boulanger has built a two-star hotel room where the militralised Berlin Wall border strip used to run. It has a double-bed, a shower, TV, but has no window as it is a room built inside a billboard block (ITN, 2009). The Single Room Hotel was a project to explore "concerns linked to architecture and inconspicuousness in an urban environment and reveals the mechanisms of production and development of temporarily marginalized spaces" at Skulpturenpark Berlin Zentrum, and guests could book the 32m sq room for 29.95 euro (Boulanger, 2008).

Boulanger, E. (2008) Single Room Hotel Berlin. [online] http://www.etienneboulanger.com/singleroomhotel/ [14/03/2010] 
ITN (2009) Windowless Hotel Launched in Berlin. [online] http://itn.co.uk/1a75e8bc70a54b1710dd8159bee12041.html [14/03/2010]
Skulpturenpark Berlin Zentrum (2007) Exhibitions : Spekulationen - November 2007 - March 2008. [online] http://www.skulpturenpark.org/exhibit/spekexhibit/boul.html [14/03/2010]

Questions Asked, 20 Years On

What caused the Berlin Wall to open up, leading onto the changes in Europe, and how did the changes follow? Packer (2009) claims "multiplicity of conditions" - such as dissidents' protests and the American support, failing economy in the Eastern bloc, the loss of confidence among the ruling elites, and Gorbachev's forbearing attitude - brought changes in Europe in 1989. Packer argues that it was a rare combination of circumstances and it should not be expected generally;
"a false lesson drawn from 1989 involves a kind of shallow eschatology of totalitarianism: this is how it always happens—the people rise up, the regime withers and dies, peace and democracy reign." (Packer, 2009)

By Tom Bachtell 

There are doubts about how democracy had prevailed over other political ideals, as Fukuyama (1989) proclaimed, we have reached "the end point of mankind's ideological evolution and the universalization of Western liberal democracy". Morozov (2009) writes that even though the world is more democratic than it was 20 years ago, it is not as democratic as we expected. Authoritarian governments have taken up technology and new media and raptures of within oppresive states are caused by globalisation, not technology, he claims. "The Berlin Wall may have fallen, but the Chinese Firewall has been erected in its place" (Morozov, 2008).

O MURO QUE DIVIDIA
UMA CIDADE - E O MUNDO by Neal Levene (2009)

Fukuyama, F. (1989) The End of History? The National Interest, Summer 1989. [online] http://www.unc.edu/home/rlstev/Text/Fukuyama%20End%20of%20History.pdf [14/03/2010]
Levene, N. (2009) Infographic: Berlin Wall. [online] http://simplecomplexity.net/berlin-wall/ [14/03/2010]
Morozov, E. (2009) TED and Reddit interview Evgeny Morozov. [online] http://blog.ted.com/2009/10/evgeny_morozov.php [14/03/2010]
Morozov, E. (2008) Digital Renegades, or Captives? [online] http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/11/opinion/11iht-edmorozov.1.18595125.html?_r=1 [14/03/2010]
Packer, G. (2009) November 9th. [online] http://www.newyorker.com/talk/comment/2009/11/16/091116taco_talk_packer [14/03/2010]

Helmut Kohl: No Team Player

The German Chancellor Helmut Kohl announced his 10-point unification plan less than 3 weeks after the opening of the Wall, where he had made no discussion with his coalition partners in Bonn, nor with the allies (Blitz, 2009 & American Embassy Bonn, 1989).


This did not help the situation which Blitz (2009) describe, that “within days of the wall coming down, euphoria had given way to dissent as the leaders of Britain and France contemplated the imminent emergence of a united Germany”. He also rejected the GDR's leader Hans Modrow's proposal on neutral Germany, in February 1990 (Bureau of European and Eurasian Affairs, 2009), which could imply that he did not reflect many views regarding the unification of Germany.

American Embassy Bonn (1989) Page 01: Bonn 37736 01 Of 02 011749Z. [online] http://www.wilsoncenter.org/cwihp/documentreaders/eotcw/891201b.pdf [14/03/2010]
Blitz, J. (2009) Mitterrand Feared Emergence of ‘Bad’ Germans. [online] http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/886192ba-9d7d-11de-9f4a-00144feabdc0.html?nclick_check=1 [14/03/2010]
Bozo, F. (2009) Thatcher’s European Delusions. [online] http://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/2009/11/thatchers-european-delusions/ [14/03/2010]

Bureau of European and Eurasian Affairs (2009) Background Note: Germany. [online] http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/3997.htm [14/03/2010] 
GHDI (trans. Riemer, J.) (1989) Helmut Kohl's Ten-Point Plan for German Unity (November 28, 1989). [online] http://germanhistorydocs.ghi-dc.org/sub_document.cfm?document_id=223 [14/03/2010]
Volkery, C. (2009) The Iron Lady's Views on German Reunification: 'The Germans Are Back!' [online] http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/0,1518,648364,00.html [14/03/2010]

Friday, 12 March 2010

RSA Berlin Wall Panel Symposia



The Renaissance Society of America organised a panel discussion on the 20th anniversary of the Wall's opening, with Mary Elise Sarotte, Peter Millar and Thomas Kielinger.

RSA (2009) Panel Discussion - The Fall of the Berlin Wall: 20 Years On. [online]
http://www.thersa.org/events/vision/vision-videos/panel-discussion-the-fall-of-the-berlin-wall-20-years-on [12/03/2010]

Thomas Macho on Anniversary



The cultural studies scholar Thomas Macho found the 20th anniversary of the opening of the Berlin Wall "a bit silly" (Thomas, 2010). "The dominoes, knocking them over, the musical background – it was all rather too playful" Macho criticized the event too-focused on TV audience; "The Wall wasn’t some rickety affair; it was quite solid, and many people died trying to cross it".


He also noted that there is a confusion about how Berlin accepts its history, and how victims of the GDR are treated.

BBC (2009) In Pictures: Berlin Wall Anniversary. [online] 
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8350810.stm [12/03/2010]
Thomas, V. (trans. Uhlaner, J.) (2010) “Every Place Is Doubly or Triply Occupied.” – Thomas Macho on Celebration in the Berlin Republic. [online]
http://www.goethe.de/ges/en5669339.htm [12/03/2010]

Divide after the Wall, 12 Nov 1989

"There will come a day when the Germans in the G.D.R. decide whether they want to form one state with the Germans in the Federal Republic... the Federal Republic will have to face up to its provisional character, which will be hard for a lot of people'' (Frankfurter Allgemeine, in Schmemann, 1989). Schmemann forecasts that unification will not be easy or simple, noting that demonstrators in the GDR with slogans "We are staying here" shows their pride and identity is not for a unified Germany.

After the opening of the Wall and free elections to follow, "the wall was reduced to a benign fence between neighboring cousins", he reported from East Berlin. "The opening of the Brandenburg Gate would not only make it unnecessary to have a wall, it might also make it unnecessary to take the wall down" (Schmemann, 1989)

Schmemann, S. (1989) Beyond the Wall; Not Just One German Question But Many. [online] http://www.nytimes.com/1989/11/12/weekinreview/beyond-the-wall-not-just-one-german-question-but-many.html [12/03/2010]

Thursday, 11 March 2010

picture book story


"It was a weird wall.
Like the Möbius strip,
it had only one side,
the other was unseen:
the far side of the Moon."

 - It was a Weird Wall by Vera Pavlova, translated by Steven Seymour
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2009/11/08/opinion/08berlinpoems.html?8dpc

"Whether 'home' is imagined as the community of Europe or of the national state or of the region, it is drenched in the longing for wholeness, unity, integrity" (Morley and Robins, 1996, in Mitchell)

Title: Two Bears of Berlin (working title)

Theme: The changes in Germany since the unification 20 years ago, with differences of perceptions ("the Wall in the mind") that still exist. Highlighting the perceptions of former-East and -West Berliners through the eyes of two bears (which represent Berlin) the readers will acknowledge that the existence of different opinions in a pluralistic society is a positive cultural state.

Time span: From the morning when the bears wake up, until they go back to sleep (or hibernation) in the night. April?

Characters: A female bear from East Berlin and a male bear from West Berlin. I'm going to call them Katarina (K) and Fritz (F) for now. They have just woken up from 20 years' hibernation (their relationship is similar to that of left and right brain, inseparable yet diverse). They are very different. Katarina only knows East Germany, where the state controlled a large part of life and also providing a lot; Fritz is more comfortable with individualist and materialist cultures, and doesn't rely much on other people. So... Katarina might be upset because the price of honey has doubled, and Fritz would complain that there are only 8 brands of honey; Katarina talks to her neighbors a lot, and Fritz won't care much about them... things like that.

Some stereotypes of East and West Berliners: http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,3927596,00.html

Ideas and resources:
The idea of a person waking up into a completely changed world is also seen in the film, Goodbye Lenin!
The film The Lives of Others talks about the life of a secret police officer before and after the opening of the Berlin Wall.
Fatherland is a story of a musician who defects to West germany and looks for his father.
The Wings of Desire is about an angel who wants to become a person, and is set in Berlin during the Wall.


The story
Berlin, 2010 - two bears, Katarina and Fritz, have woken up from their hibernation. Katarina and Fritz have never met before, although they lived on a same hill. In fact, they only lived few metres away from each other. This is because there used to be a long wall that separated the hill, but Katarina and Fritz have overslept a little. They have been sleeping for more than 20 years, so they didn’t know anything about the events in 1989 which opened up the wall and changed their hill.

---

Title

---

A short introduction

---

P1
It was a bright cold day in April, and it was nearly noon.
[Fritz wakes up, scratching his ass, when he sees Katarina coming out of her house/hole. They look at each other, embarrassed]

---

P2
"Who are you?", asked F. "And what are you doing on my field?"
[K] "I've lived here ALL my life. This is my field, and this is my house, right next to the...

---

P3
"Where is the Wall?"

---

P4
"You mush have been a sleep for a long time," said an old voice from below.
[a mole comes out of the ground]
"The Wall has been gone for more than 20 years now" said the mole. "East Bearland is gone too", he continued, "Now there's just one Bearland".

---

P5
K + F: "WOW!"
For as long as they knew, the Bearland had been divided into two, East and West. Neither of them could imagine that two Bearlands would ever be together.

K, excitedly: "I'm free now. I'm going to see what's on the other side."

---

P6
[a street with lots of adverts and posters]
There are so many adverts" said K, a little shocked. "But", interrupted F, "that's because there are lots of shops." "And lots of food", he added.

---

P7
K: "But why do you need so much?" One official brand was enough for K, and she grew up that way.  One official brand was enough for K, she'd grown up that way.
[a loud car drives pass K]
K: "And, there are too many cars." Bears had to wait for 5 years in East Bearland to get a car, but K would always get a lift from her neighbours. Lots of bears living on her street shared that car. 

When refering to 'that car' I think the audience would need some frame of reference to remember back to - even if it was just a picture of the car in a memory bubble as K remembers it? Otherwise the sentence should say something like, 'that beat up car,' or 'that little Ford Fiesta'...Or some native car to Berlin. does this make sense to you? Like, giving some description so it doesn't feel like there's missing information.
I'm picky - it might not matter.

---

P8
K wondered how many years bears had to wait in West Bearland. "It's not West Bearland any more" K thought to herself. There was just one Bearland.
F: "Here, you don't have to wait when you buy a car" siad F confidently, interrupting her thoughts. "And they go MUCH faster than any cars made in East Bearland!" he claimed, triumphantly. "You can go anywhere, fast!"

---

P9
K wondered how her father was doing. Her father had wanted to buy a car. Usually, the bears had to wait for 5 years for their car to be delivered, but because K's father was an official of the Bearland government, he was told he only had to wait for 3 years. "But" K thought, if there was no East Bearland, he wouldn't have a job any more. 

---

P10
"If no bears had jobs, how can they afford to pay for their cars?"
[K looks at F] "I bet he doesn't have a job" thought K.

---

P11
F was starting to worry too, because K kept looking at him in a strange way. "Maybe she works for the Secret Bear Police." F had heard about the Secret Bear Police in East Bearland (but he didn't know it had dissapeared with East Bearland). K continued to look around. Are you keeping the brackets here? Yup.


---

P12
They were both a bit tired of each other.   

---

P13
K and F stopped, and looked up the Wall. The Wall that cut the Bearland into two, and seperated bear families, for years and years... but this bit of the Wall just stood there. No bears seemed to notice the Wall. Now it was just like a normal wall.

---

P14
They looked at the Wall. K saw the clouds move slowly across the sky. F noticed the birds singing, and playing together. "I wonder which bird is from the East and which from the West". The sky was never divided by the Wall.

---

P15
K felt a bit of Spring wind on her fur [which swirls around her, brushes pass F, plays with blossoms and then goes over the Wall. F gives a long sigh] 

---

P16
[and then, they they see a group of bees fly over the Wall. they make patterns in the air. Bears' stomach growl. they look at each other and smile] 
The bees had always flown over the wall to make honey.

---

P17
[the sun is starting to set]
"I'm really hungry" they both said, [look surprised] and smiled again. They hadn't had anything to eat for a long time. They'd been walking and looking around since they met - and arguing.

---

P18
"Let's go home and eat some honey" said F. 

---

P19
There were lots of things they wanted to talk about.

---

P20
[stars in the sky]
So they headed back home.

Tomo, this is so CUTE! Hope I haven't added too much. I've only done a quick look of it and written about the things that jump out at me. It's not my story though, and don't want to feel like I'm taking over, sorry if some of the comments look a bit fierce. Let me know if you don't like what I've been saying though. Oh, and sorry that what I've written is a bit hard to find x